Witch flounder, Grey sole, Torbay sole
Witch is a small to medium-sized flatfish with an elongated, oval body and both eyes positioned on the right side of its head. It has a smooth, greyish-brown upper surface and a pale underside, with a relatively small mouth and prominent eyes. It can grow to around 60cm in length, although most commercially caught specimens are considerably smaller.
Its flesh is white, delicate and mildly flavoured, making it a versatile fish for cooking.
Witch is found across the northern Atlantic, including the northeast Atlantic around Britain, Ireland, Iceland and northern Europe, as well as the northwest Atlantic off North America.
It primarily inhabits deeper waters, typically at depths of 100–400 metres, favouring soft seabeds consisting of mud, clay or clean sand. It feeds on small crustaceans, marine worms, brittle stars and other fish.
In UK waters, it is particularly associated with the northern North Sea and areas west of the British Isles, although it also occurs in the Celtic Sea and English Channel.
Sustainability Rating
Status: Witch stocks are not well understood in many fishing areas, with limited scientific information available to assess population levels accurately. Scientific advice has raised concerns about excessive fishing pressure in some northeast Atlantic fisheries. It is relatively slow-growing and can live for more than 20 years, making it vulnerable to sustained fishing pressure.
Best Choice: There is currently insufficient evidence to recommend witch from poorly assessed fisheries as a sustainable seafood choice. Any sourcing decision should be based on the latest scientific advice for the specific stock and fishing area.
Avoid: Witch from fisheries where fishing pressure is considered excessive or where stock health cannot be demonstrated. Fish smaller than 28cm should also be avoided to help protect immature individuals.
Culinary Uses
Witch has delicate, white flesh with a mild, slightly sweet flavour.
Excellent pan-fried, baked or gently poached.
Its fine texture works particularly well with butter, lemon, herbs and light sauces.
Witch can also be prepared whole or served as fillets, making it a versatile alternative to other flatfish in traditional seafood dishes.
Best Fishing Practices
Witch is generally caught as part of mixed fisheries targeting other whitefish species, rather than through dedicated commercial fisheries.
Improved stock assessments and more comprehensive catch recording are important for understanding fishing pressure and establishing appropriate management measures.
Protecting juvenile fish is particularly important. A minimum landing size of 28cm applies in some UK coastal fisheries, helping prevent immature fish from being retained.
As witch grows relatively slowly and reaches sexual maturity at around three to four years of age, effective catch management is essential for maintaining healthy populations.
Seasonality
Witch can be available throughout much of the year, although spawning generally takes place during the summer months.
The preferred months for consumption are January to March and August to December, avoiding the main spring and summer spawning period. However, seasonal availability does not override concerns about stock health or fishing pressure.
Supporting Local, Sustainable Seafood
Witch highlights the importance of reliable scientific information when assessing seafood sustainability. Although it is a versatile flatfish with delicate, flavoursome flesh, limited stock assessments and concerns about fishing pressure make responsible sourcing difficult.
Choosing alternative flatfish from healthier, well-managed stocks can help reduce pressure on vulnerable witch populations while supporting improvements in fisheries monitoring and management.
Book now
Join us at Faber Restaurant to explore our menu. Book a table today using the form below or call us on 0208 161 9800 if you have any special requirements.
